Once we realized that two thirds of the restaurants on the island were not open/not an option even if open, we were sooo happy to see Poseidon’s Pantry open. It’s a takeout deli/grocery store of sorts – We got sandwiches three times and each time we were really happy with the meal. They carry Quorn Turk’y Roast and some Beyond Meat products as well. They have a mix of vegan, vegetarian, and meaty options and the owners are really friendly.
This is definitely a great place to go for a veggie sandwich on Chincoteague Island!